Armenian Rights Group Files Ethics Complaint Against Pashinian

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian gesturing as he speaks during a news briefing in Yerevan (file photo)
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian gesturing as he speaks during a news briefing in Yerevan (file photo)

A human rights organization has filed an ethics complaint with Armenia’s anti-corruption body against Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian after he repeatedly called a reporter “contemptible” during a news briefing.

Taguhi Tovmasian, a former opposition lawmaker and newspaper editor who heads the Power of Speech nongovernmental organization, asked the Corruption Prevention Commission to examine Pashinian’s conduct and determine whether he violated ethical standards for public officials.

The complaint follows a November 19 news briefing in which Pashinian yelled at journalist Hripsime Jebejian after she questioned why he had not died in the Nagorno-Karabakh war, echoing remarks the prime minister had himself previously directed at critics, and noted the expansion of Yerevan’s Yerablur military cemetery during his tenure.

“You personally, and many journalists and politicians like you, have for a long time been using Yerablur as small change for your narrow journalistic purposes and narrow interests,” Pashinian shouted at Jebejian. “You are contemptible in doing that. You are contemptible, you personally.”

In a statement announcing the filing, Tovmasian said that directing repeated “humiliating remarks” at a journalist carrying out her professional duties constitutes an apparent violation of public officials’ rules of conduct.

The Corruption Prevention Commission has not yet responded to the petition. Phone calls from RFE/RL’s Armenian Service seeking comment on whether the body will open proceedings went unanswered.

The Union of Journalists of Armenia also condemned the prime minister’s recent remarks, accusing him of declaring “war on journalists.”

“We call on the Armenian authorities to immediately cease hostile rhetoric toward journalists, refrain from attempts to discredit and intimidate them in their professional activities, and recognize that disrespectful treatment of a journalist is not merely that individual journalist’s problem, but a blow to freedom of speech and the fundamental values of a democratic society,” the organization said in a statement.

The dispute widened on Friday when Armenia’s first president, Levon Ter-Petrosian, broke his usual public silence to endorse the Union of Journalists’ statement. Ter-Petrosian, who leads the opposition Armenian National Congress party, accused Pashinian of using “profanity-laced language” and displaying “vulgar behavior” unprecedented among Armenian leaders, calling on international human rights watchdogs to assess the prime minister’s democratic record.

Pashinian, who was a close ally of Ter-Petrosian during the 2008 presidential election before they parted ways politically, fired back on Facebook. He accused the former president of “establishing a tradition of violence against journalists in Armenia, founding the Yerablur military cemetery, dragging the country into conflict and war to gain power, and falsifying constitutional referendum and election results.”

The controversy comes amid other recent verbal clashes involving the prime minister, who earlier this week used derogatory slang, calling opposition Hayastan faction lawmaker Mesrop Manukian a “lackey,” “bear-scratcher,” and “slipper-holder.”

Pashinian insisted those remarks generally characterized Manukian’s previous duties as an assistant to General Manvel Grigorian, a late Karabakh war field commander and former lawmaker notorious for violent behavior.

It is not the first time Pashinian, a former newspaper editor, has faced scrutiny over his language from the anti-corruption watchdog. Last year, the Corruption Prevention Commission ruled that the prime minister had violated the official code of conduct by using vulgar and insulting language in a Facebook post and in separate public remarks. Following those rulings, Pashinian issued an apology while stating he did not fully agree with all of the commission’s assessments.

XS
SM
MD
LG